Eric Andre hit Instagram with a cute photo of himself and his girlfriend on Valentine’s Day – but seeing as he’s a comedian, no one really took him seriously when he suddenly revealed he’s dating the one and only Rosario Dawson. Twitter – and Chance the Rapper, for that matter – were in actual disbelief.

“Happy Valentine’s Day to my Boo-Bay,” he captioned the beautiful photo, at which point social media began to react:

Chance even texted Rosario to see if it was a prank:

But the proof is in the pudding…

How bou dah?

[ione_media_gallery id=”4204974″ overlay=”true”]